Shipt vs Instacart: Which Grocery Delivery Service Pays More?

by Colin Parker in , Comment — Updated Reading Time: 7 minutes

Do you want to earn extra money by delivering groceries?

If you enjoy doing groceries, then start it as a side gig. It’s much more peaceful than driving people around, and if you enjoy shopping, it can be fun.

You do not know where to start?

Fret not,

Platforms like Shipt and Instacart provide you with jobs, including grocery shopping for other people according to their demands.

But the question arises here. Which one is the better?

Here’s a review of both these platforms and how they are similar and different from each other.

Working for Shipt or Instacart: Which one pays more?

Shipt Vs Instacart: Which Grocery Delivery Service Pays More? Photo

For those looking to boost their income through the gig economy, grocery delivery services like Instacart or Shipt offer viable options. Many are eager to find out which platform offers a better working experience.

Therefore, the discussion about choosing Instacart vs Shipt as a side hustle is ongoing. Both platforms have unique benefits and challenges that impact overall shopper satisfaction.

Instacart shoppers often praise the flexibility of choosing their schedules and orders. This autonomy makes it better to work for those who need to juggle various responsibilities.

Conversely, some argue that it’s better to work for Shipt due to its less competitive shopper environment. Both platforms provide different perks that appeal to diverse worker preferences.

The comparison of both these platforms revolves around more than just earnings and schedules. It also encompasses job responsibilities and the quality of support provided to shoppers.

Ultimately, choosing between these two comes down to personal work style and financial goals. Both platforms offer opportunities, but aligning with the one that best fits your needs is crucial for success.

What is Shipt?

Shipt Vs Instacart: Which Grocery Delivery Service Pays More? Photo

This platform was founded in 2014 and later acquired by Target. It operates in the majority of American cities and caters primarily to grocery stores.

The platform promotes a friendly, community-oriented attitude, encouraging shoppers to build positive relationships with other customers. Shipt offers a model where orders are often scheduled ahead of time, which helps streamline the delivery process.

What is Instacart?

Shipt Vs Instacart: Which Grocery Delivery Service Pays More? Photo

Instacart, founded in 2012, has expanded significantly and now serves a broad market across the United States and Canada. It is available in numerous stores of grocery, and shoppers can choose their preferred shopping style.

Moreover, shoppers can opt for in-store shopping, where they simply collect items, or full-service shopping, which includes placing and delivering orders. This flexibility ensures that Instacart also caters to different preferences and schedules.

Which one is the better?

Here is a concise comparison table highlighting key differences and similarities between the two grocery delivery services:

1.Comparing pay structures

Both boast potential earnings of $20-$25 per hour, influenced by factors such as order size, location, and tips. If you’re considering working at the company, it’s vital to understand their payment structures.

Shipt compensates its shoppers with a commission based on the total order amount, allowing them to keep 100% of their tips. Shoppers appreciate the simplicity of weekly payments, especially during peak times when promotional bonuses don’t pay out immediately.

At Shipt, the best part of working there is receiving consistent weekly payments through direct deposit. The company culture, like the company, nurtures a supportive environment, often boosting morale with bonus incentives during busy periods.

Instacart’s compensation model is a bit more complex, combining a variable base pay with tips. This setup might necessitate a comparison of working at Instacart to Shipt, especially regarding earnings predictability and the effort required.

For those who don’t want to wait for their money, Instacart offers an Instant Cashout feature, which allows for quicker access to earnings for a small fee. It’s a favorite among Instacart shoppers and Shipt drivers alike who need immediate funds.

Understanding the nuances of each platform can significantly impact your experience and satisfaction as a gig worker. Both companies offer unique advantages that cater to different preferences and needs in the gig economy landscape.

2.Flexible and Scheduling

The scheduled shopping windows required by Shipt streamline your day, making it simpler to integrate this gig with your daily routine. However, this structure might curb spontaneity, a stressful part about working within such rigid time constraints, especially if you value flexibility.

On the other hand, Instacart enhances work flexibility, offering the freedom to choose shifts on the fly through its on-demand system. This feature is perfect for those who dislike a fixed schedule and prefer adapting their work hours as they go.

In terms of the work environment and culture at both companies, Shipt promotes a community-oriented atmosphere where shopper interactions are encouraged, potentially making it a more supportive work environment. Instacart leans more towards an independent approach, where interactions are less frequent, suiting those who prefer working solo.

When we get a comparison of working between Instacart and Shipt, the difference in shopper experience stands out. Shipt often requires visiting multiple stores like Costco, adding a layer of complexity to the shopping process but also increasing the potential for higher delivery fees.

Regarding compensation, Instacart Express members can save on delivery fees, which could influence earnings positively if the frequency of orders increases. Meanwhile, Shipt is better known for offering consistent hourly pay, which might be more appealing to those looking for a stable income.

Both Instacart and Shipt provide unique advantages depending on what you prioritize in a gig economy role. Whether it’s Shipt’s community feel and scheduled shifts or Instacart’s flexible, high-autonomy model, both platforms provide viable paths to earning in the gig economy.

3.Job Demand and Ease

Shipt is known for its interactive approach, often resulting in a shopper engaging more deeply with customers during store visits. This method, though time-consuming, can lead to larger tips, bolstering the reasons why Shipt is most highly rated for customer service.

On the other hand, Instacart prioritizes speed and efficiency in its operations. The app’s design simplifies the process of accepting orders, making it easier for shoppers to find out if Instacart is right for them based on how quickly they prefer to work.

For those looking to compare salary information for Instacart and Shipt, it’s notable that both platforms offer potential earnings boosts through customer tips. However, these can vary widely based on how interactive and efficient shoppers are during their runs.

Comparing ratings between the two services reveals different shopper preferences. Instacart’s focus on swift service appeals to those who value quick, straightforward shopping experiences.

Additionally, both services participate in the broader food delivery market, which includes competitors like DoorDash. This sector continues to grow, offering various opportunities for gig workers.

Ultimately, choosing between Shipt and Instacart may depend on individual work style preferences and local market conditions. Both offer unique benefits, making them valuable options in the competitive food delivery industry.

4.Comparing Salaries

When considering ways to make money in the gig economy, particularly if you want to send groceries, it’s vital to weigh the potential earnings of Shipt versus Instacart.

Shipt membership perks often include free deliveries on orders, which is a boon for both shoppers and customers.

For those who have access to a vehicle, Instacart’s flexible scheduling for full-service shoppers appeals to those looking to work without rigid time constraints.

Comparing salaries and ratings to find the best platform can influence your decision, as each offers different financial and experiential benefits.

Instacart allows shoppers to work up to 29 hours per week as in-store associates, presenting a consistent but limited earning opportunity.

Finally, both services operate across a network of local grocery stores, enhancing the convenience factor in your shopping and delivery tasks.

Here’s a comparison table outlining the salaries for various roles at Shipt and Instacart:

5.Shopper Support and Community

Shipt is renowned for its robust community, where shoppers connect via forums and social media. This engagement helps them share insights and experiences, fostering a strong sense of belonging.

Instacart as well boasts a large community, but the level of support can be inconsistent. Some users report excellent assistance, while others struggle to get help via the Instacart app during challenging times.

When it comes to overall shopper satisfaction, it often depends on what you value most in a gig. Whether you choose Shipt for its community and predictable schedule or Instacart for its flexibility, your preference will shape your experience.

Shipt also offers a more structured and reassuring environment. Both platforms provide opportunities but in different ways.

This platform involves a detailed process where you interact closely with customers. This process includes using a provided payment card to pay for the order when you check out.

On the other hand, Instacart allows for more spontaneous work, where you pick and deliver groceries as orders come in. This can lead to quicker payouts and a dynamic workday.

6.Work Environment and Culture

When comparing the work environment and culture at Instacart versus Shipt, there are some key differences to consider.

Instacart is available in more areas, making it a more widespread option for those looking to become a shopper. On the other hand, Shipt is not as widely available, which may limit opportunities for potential Shipt shoppers.

In terms of pay, Shipt pays its buyers right, but Instacart also offers similar salaries to their employees. The culture at each company also varies, with Instacart asking that shoppers shop and deliver from stores like Aldi, while Shipt focuses more on the delivery aspect, offering free delivery on orders for their customers.

In terms of company reviews and ratings, it can be helpful to compare working at Instacart versus Shipt. While both companies have positive reviews overall, it’s important to look at the specific details to see which company may be the right fit for you.

When comparing company information and interview processes, Instacart or Shipt also have their own unique approaches. Instacart is known for its easy-to-use app and quick delivery times, while Shipt prides itself on its personalized customer service and attention to detail.


1. How do the company reviews for Instacart and Shipt compare?

When comparing the company reviews of Shipt vs Instacart, it’s important to consider factors such as job satisfaction, work-life balance, and compensation. Generally, Shipt tends to receive higher ratings in terms of overall customer satisfaction and driver experience.

2. Why is Shipt considered the right choice for some?

Shipt is often considered a preferred option by some due to its flexible scheduling, competitive pay rates, and focus on personal shopper experience. Additionally, Shipt’s partnership with Target provides access to a wide range of products not available on other platforms.

3. Can you provide a comparison of company information between Instacart and Shipt?

While both platforms offer grocery services, the companies differ in terms of operating regions, service fees, and technological features. Shipt generally emphasizes a more personalized approach, while Instacart focuses on partnerships with various grocery stores.

4. How do the company ratings of Instacart and Shipt compare?

In terms of customer satisfaction and driver experience, Shipt often receives higher ratings than Instacart. However, ratings can vary based on location, individual experiences, and delivery preferences.

Wrapping Up

Choosing between Shipt and Instacart hinges on your preferences for gig economy roles. If structured schedules and customer service and communication are key for you, Shipt stands out, especially since shoppers can use the app to manage orders in the app effectively.

On the other hand, Instacart shines if you value the ability to pick your own hours and earn more per order. Both platforms are available in more cities, offer pay per delivery model, and include notable benefits for shoppers like free grocery delivery, making them attractive options in the evolving gig economy.



Share this article

Leave a Comment